Thursday, July 2 2015

            We Deliver News to the Sierra
News Fire News spacer Latest News spacer Regional News spacer California News spacer USA News spacer World News spacer Op-Ed spacer Enviro News spacer Sci Tech News spacer Life spacer Odd News spacer Cartoons spacer
Features The Calendar features features Weather features Sierra NightSky features features features Road Conditions features Home spacer

Dan Bacher: Coastal Commission rejects PG&E seismic testing plan


By: Dan Bacher

Greenpeace and Sea Shepherd activists showed in force to oppose seismic testing at the Coastal Commission meeting in Santa Monica on November 14. Photo by Dan Bacher.
Nov. 16, 2012 - The California Coastal Commission voted unanimously on Wednesday, November 14 to reject Pacific Gas and Electric Company's widely-contested plan to conduct seismic testing off the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant. They found the plan inconsistent with the California Coastal Act.

In a massive display of unity, hundreds of fishermen, Tribal members and environmentalists showed up to oppose the plan at the standing room-only meeting in Santa Monica. Only one person - Mark Krause, the spokesman of PG&E - spoke in favor of the plan.

Plan opponents wore colorful T-shirts and sweatshirts emblazoned with slogans such as "Seismic Matters" and "Stop the Diablo Canyon Seismic Testing," and held up an array of signs and banners with messages ranging from "Make Love Not Noise" to the AIM Banner, "We are the First Americans of this Great Land."

"The Coastal Band of the Chumash Nation, a sovereign nation, calls on all peoples to protect our marine relatives and all of our sacred sites on land or in the water, registered or not," Crystal Baker, Board Member of the Coastal Band of the Chumash Nation, told the Commission. "PG&E's own Environmental Impact Report acknowledges that the proposed testing will have 'significant and unavoidable impacts' to marine life on our Indigenous Sacred Sites and the Public Safety."

The high energy testing would have resulted in potential injury and death to thousands of whales, dolphins and other marine mammals, along with chinook salmon, steelhead, rockfish, halibut and a host of fish species, according to those who testified. They agreed with the Coastal Commission staff, who urged the Commission to reject the permit, since the danger posed to marine life would be great while the information to be obtained by the survey could be obtained by analyzing existing data. (http://documents.coastal.ca.gov/reports)

The testing would have impacted marine life in the Point Buchon State Marine Reserve and other marine protected areas that went into effect in September 2007 under the Marine Life Protection Act (MLPA) Initiative.

After hearing public comment, the Commissioners, one by one, explained their reasons for opposing the approval of the permit. "These tests are not going to do us any good in terms of protecting the public welfare - and the environmental impacts of this project were understated," said commissioner Jana Zimmer.

Some Commissioners voiced their support for closing Diablo Canyon and other nuclear power plants. "I personally believe the state is asking the wrong question," said Mary Shallenberger, Commission Chair. "We should be asking how to get nuclear plants off our coast."

Likewise, Commissioner Martha McClure stated, "It's time to close these plants. It's time to convert them over to solar energy."

Representatives of Indian Tribes, environmental organizations and fishing groups celebrated the Commission decision.

Fred Collins, Administrator for the Northern Chumash Tribal Council, praised the decision. "Mother Earth, our ancestors, the animal nation and the animal nation were all heard with one resounding voice. We must care for all things," said Collins.

Joey Racano of the Stop Diablo Canyon Seismic Testing Facebook Community (www.facebook.com/StopTheDiabloCanyonSeismicTesting) stated, "The Commission thoughtfully made the right choice that they can't do it here. In case PG&E comes back again, we will be watching."

"We are pleased the California Coastal Commission strongly upheld the Coastal Act by denying this terribly harmful project," said Stefanie Sekich-Quinn, Surfrider Foundation's California Policy Manager. "The large public attendance today demonstrates just how citizens can greatly influence decision makers. Surfrider Foundation believes taxpayers, ocean users and marine life are better off because of this decision."

The project, proposed under the auspices of gathering information for the Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, would have involved towing powerful air cannons off the Central Coast, shooting deafening underwater explosions (upwards of 250 decibels) every 13 seconds for 17 straight days.

The Surfrider Foundation, Greenpeace, Sea Shepherd, Stop Diablo Canyon Testing Facebook Community and other environmental and fishing groups groups maintain that similar surveying information already exists and the project unnecessarily puts marine life at risk.

"We thank the Coastal Commissioners and staff for taking a stand in defense protection our coastal recreation and marine life. While everyone wants a safe nuclear power plant at Diablo Canyon, this project was not the right way to get there, says Dr. Chad Nelsen, Surfrider Foundation's Environmental Director. "The threats from seismic testing to marine wildlife and ocean recreation are so severe it should be considered the last resort, not business as usual."

Marcus Lopez, Co-Chair of the Barbareno Chumash Council of Santa Barbara, said, "Congratulations to all who participated to defend our relatives! What we did do is to be a good ancestor in that we defended the voiceless in our people's terms. We were the voice of the voiceless." (http://northernchumash.wordpress.com/news)

"We had a United Front consisting of Northern Chumash Council, Coastal Band of the Chumash Nation, the Wishtoyo Foundation, the Seventh Generation Fund for Indigenous Development and the American Indian Movement of Southern California. It also included the many local and not so local individuals that gave their support and time to let others of the non-Indian and Indian Peoples understand this all important topic. This issue is not "dead;" our vigilance is vital."

Corine Fairbanks of the American Indian Movement Southern California Chapter summed up the meeting. "It was a wonderful day - over 300 people in attendance at the Coastal Commission meeting regarding the PG&E proposed seismic testing off the coast of Central California. Over 175 people signed on to make public comment on November 14, and the Chumash Delegation, including Angela Mooney-D'Arcy, of the Acjachemen Nation, made some key points that were not being addressed, stopping the entire room with an eloquent and powerful delivery," she stated.

Zeke Grader, executive director of the Pacific Coast Federation of Fisherman's Associations, said, "We're pleased and hope this is the last we see of PG&E's plan. The good news is that this it has drawn to public attention the seismic surveys, which are used extensively by the offshore oil industry."

"The other good news is that many of the proponents of the marine protected areas created under the MLPA Initiative are starting to wake up to the fact that fishing is just one small part of protecting the ocean. A lot of other things need to be considered, including pollution, offshore oil drilling, noise impacts and future development such as offshore aquaculture and deep sea mining," Grader concluded.

There is no doubt that the huge outpouring of opposition by a diverse community of Tribal representatives, environmentalists, recreational anglers and commercial fishermen sent a clear and unmistakable message - the people of California will not allow their government to sacrifice whales, dolphins, salmon, halibut, rockfish and other marine life at the "altar" of corporate greed.


Help us bring you more news. Be a real reader: Support YubaNet

By submitting a comment you consent to our rules. You must use your real first and last name, not a nickname or alias. A comment here is just like a letter to the editor or a post on Facebook. Thank you.


Latest Headlines


State Reduces Water Use by Nearly 29 Percent In Advance of June Conservation Mandates

Mendocino National Forest enters fire restrictions

Highest Threat from Oil Trains in California Aligned with Race and Income: New Environmental Justice Report Links Dangerous Rail Routes with Census Data

Happy and safe Independence Day from your Modoc National Forest

U.S. EPA to approve California’s newest list of impaired waterways

Fire Restrictions on the Klamath National Forest Begin Thursday July 2nd

State Health Officer Warns of the Dangers of Excessive Heat

New Tests Find Toxic Cocktail in Santa Barbara Spill

Californians urged to severely limit outdoor watering this summer






NEWS . Fire News . Latest . Regional . California . USA . World . Op-Ed . Enviro . Sci/Tech . Life . Odd News . Cartoons
FEATURES . The Calendar .Weather . Sierra NightSky. Road Conditions
YubaNet.com . Advertising. About Us . Support YubaNet . Contact Us . Terms of Use . Privacy

YubaNet.com © 1999-2015
Nevada City, California (530) 478-9600