YubaNet.com
Saturday, May 17 2008

            We Deliver News to the Sierra
News Fire News spacer Latest News spacer Regional News spacer California News spacer USA News spacer World News spacer Op-Ed spacer Enviro News spacer Sci Tech News spacer Life spacer Odd News spacer Cartoons spacer
Features The Calendar features Classifieds features Weather features Sierra NightSky features Maps features YubaNet Links features Road Conditions features Home spacer
Columns
 

Martha Rosenberg: Like Many Mass Shooters, NIU Gunman Was a Legal Gun Owner

By: Martha Rosenberg

martharosenberg_1.jpgWhile the nation debates NIU shooter Stephen Phillip Kazmierczak's mental health, how many realize he waltzed into Tony's Guns in Champaign, IL five days before the massacre and bought a Remington and a Glock?

Kazmierczak may have been institutionalized for a year and given a psychological discharge from the Army, but he passed the background check just fine when he bought two of his four weapons at a Champaign, IL gun store!

So did Latina Williams who shot three at Louisiana Technical College in Baton Rouge on February 8. She might have been living in her car, paranoid and delusional and giving her possessions away in suicidal gestures but she walked right into a New Orleans pawn shop and bought a .357 revolver and a box of ammunition the day before the shootings.

It's a good guess that Charles "Cookie" Lee Thornton was a legal gun owner too when he killed two police officers, two council members, the city's public works director and shot the mayor, Mike Swoboda, twice in the head at a City Council meeting in Kirkwood, MO on February 7.

Shooters in two Valentine's Day-timed massacres last year--Sulejman Talovic who killed five in Salt Lake City's Trolley Square mall and Vincent J. Dortch who killed three at the Philadelphia Naval Shipyard--also breezed through background checks. Talovic, a Bossnian immigrant, bought his weapon at Sportsman's Fastcash, a pawn shop chain, without even showing second identification as required of legal aliens investigators think.

Bart A. Ross, a Polish immigrant who shot Federal Judge Joan Lefkow's husband and mother in Chicago 2005, was also a legal gun owner.

So were Terry Ratzmann, who fatally shot seven in a church service in Milwaukee in 2005, Chai Vang, who killed six Wisconsin hunters in 2004 and Jennifer Sanmarco who shot and killed six at a Goleta, CA postal facility in 2006.

And of course there was Virginia Tech's Seung-Hui Cho.

Of course the gun lobby likes to use mass shootings for recruitment.

Do you really want to be unarmed when a human volcano explodes because he lost his job, went off his meds or his girlfriend dumped him it asks--as if it had nothing to do with arming the volcano.

And as if "good guys" defending themselves against criminals need to purchase multiple guns and automatic weapons as the Kazmierczaks of the world typically do.

But with 20 dead in February alone, the reductionistic equation--1) bad guys get guns illegally 2) the rest of us need them because of 1)-breaks down.

It starts to look less like Outlaw Guns And Only Outlaws Will Have Guns and more like Legalize Easy Guns and Criminals Will Be Legal.

Speaking to a group of Florida Republican women on Valentine's Day before news of the NIU massacre surfaced, Glen Caroline, director of the National Rifle Association's Institute for Legislative Action lamented. "The media never reports on self-defense use of guns. They always report on criminal use of guns." Unfortunately he was about to hear about Kazmierczak.

Martha Rosenberg's work has appeared in the Chicago Tribune, L.A. Times, San Francisco Chronicle, Boston Globe, Providence Journal. Arizona Republic, New Orleans Times-Picayune and other newspapers. Now she also shares her views with YubaNet.com's readers.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button AddThis Feed Button


In the interest of fostering civil and issue-oriented discourse, YubaNet does not publish reader comments identified by anonymous Internet "handles" (fake user ID names like "farfromthinkin"). Your full and real name will be published with your comment. Your email address will not be shown, unless you specifically "uncheck" the box 'Hide my email.' By submitting a comment you consent to our rules.

Comments

Greg Moody
05 Mar 2008, 00:35
In a relativistic society, who cares if someone kills someone else? In our endeavor to remove all morals and values from the political arena, we have sent the message to people that morals elsewhere in society are also relativistic. If you fail to see where I am going with this argument...ask 10 people if we should have ended slavery. Then ask those same 10 people if we should have/end abortion. Our political solution was to end slavery by law because of the moral vacuum caused by the evil of slavery...yet opponents to abortion remove the moral equation by refusing to consider the implications of life existing since conception. Can you prove where life begins...I can't. Neither can you, but we continue to have abortion based on removing the question of right/wrong because it would be determining values for someone. It becomes a choice rather than a moral question. Returning to the question of legal guns. Will great wrong be done with a gun? Sure...who can deny that? Is the problem the gun? Let us think about this... is this a political question or a moral one? Oops! The gun is political. The act is moral. Which do you solve? I propose that the moral solution is the only one that matters. Will crimes of insanity continue to happen if we remove the gun from society (if it would even be possible or desirable)...of course they will. Can you kill 32 people with a razor sharp katana in a crowded school? Probably not, but the question is not a number problem!!! 32 or 1 makes no difference. One person is too many. The focus of our government, schools, media and other pundits need to be on morals. Why are you so afraid of introducing values into our political life? Are you really afraid that the Pope will rule America? Do you actually believe that the framers of this little experiment meant for this land to extinguish moral controversy for the sake of political agreement?
Where grave moral problems are evident, it is catastrophic to separate politics and law from moral consideration. A worthy goal to champion would be the reintroduction into "polis" of moral and religious argument. Anything else will and has impoverished our civic government and our ability to participate in that same government.


Nick Wilcox
21 Feb 2008, 03:38
Scott Thorpe, our homegrown rampage killer (January 10, 2001)was also a legal gun owner and used a registered weapon. However, he was also in possession of 11 illegal guns, a fact which our local authorities never saw fit to investigate. Sadly, guns have infiltrated so deeply into our culture that the killing will go on unabated until our politicians, like the tinman, get a heart.
*Name:
Email:
Notify me about new comments on this page
Hide my email
*Text:
Security Image:

Visual CAPTCHA


 

 
Subscribe to YubaNetNews, our weekly newsletter featuring the latest regional stories and more.


Latest Headlines

Columns

Martha Rosenberg: No Shielding of Recalled Meat Sellers in California Despite USDA Position

Andy Borowitz: 'Saturday Night Live' Abandons Comedy Format to Focus on Endorsements

Norman Solomon: The War Election

Andy Borowitz: Cash-rich Obama Buys Yahoo

Martha Rosenberg: Who Drank The Milk From Hallmark/Westland Cows?

Andy Borowitz: Nader Announces Plan to Wreck Election

Preston MacDougall: Chemical Eye on the Air Force

Andy Borowitz : Obama Calls Plagiarism Flap 'Best of Times, Worst of Times'

Martha Rosenberg: Like Many Mass Shooters, NIU Gunman Was a Legal Gun Owner

Andy Borowitz: Roger Clemens Named New White House Spokesperson


More

 
 


NEWS . Fire News . Latest . Regional . California . USA . World . Op-Ed . Enviro . Sci/Tech . Life . Odd News . Cartoons
FEATURES . The Calendar . Classifieds . Weather . Sierra NightSky . Maps . YubaNetLinks . Road Conditions
YubaNet.com . Advertising . About Us . Contact Us . Terms of Use . Privacy

YubaNet.com © 2008
Nevada City, California (530) 478-9600