Thursday, May 26 2016

            We Deliver News to the Sierra
News Fire News spacer Latest News spacer Regional News spacer California News spacer USA News spacer World News spacer Op-Ed spacer Enviro News spacer Sci Tech News spacer Life spacer Odd News spacer Cartoons spacer
Features The Calendar features features Weather features Sierra NightSky features features features Road Conditions features Home spacer

Manuel Perez-Rocha: NAFTA's 20 Years of Unfulfilled Promises

The trade deal has become an engine of poverty in Mexico


By: Manuel Perez-Rocha, OtherWords

Dec. 27, 2013 - Twenty years after it took effect, NAFTA has failed the vast majority of Mexicans.

Of course, hundreds of thousands of U.S. jobs have vanished since automotive and tech companies moved their production across the border in search of much lower wages.

This was supposed to boost employment in Mexico. Instead, NAFTA has become an engine of poverty in the country, forcing millions of Mexicans to migrate to the United States in search of jobs.


Under NAFTA, cheap subsidized corn from the United States flooded Mexico, making it impossible for millions of Mexican farmers to compete. Government support previously given to small farmers was withdrawn and directed to big agricultural exporting corporations instead.

"Before NAFTA, Mexico was a developing country," says Victor Suarez, who leads an association of Mexican small farmers. "But now it's an underdeveloping country, with 70 percent of people in rural areas and 85 percent of the indigenous population living in poverty."

Still, even with hard times in the countryside, the trade deal's architects promised that Mexico would industrialize. That transformation would, according to the promises that propelled NAFTA two decades ago, generate job growth.

Unfortunately, most factories that opened in Mexico are merely assembly plants, not production sites.

Parts arrive from the United States, China, and other countries. Once assembled, the products are exported. Without much local or national content, these industries require fewer workers than locally based manufacturing plants, which closed down when they could not compete.

Adán Rivera, who leads an association of small and medium-sized companies in Mexico, points out that because NAFTA caused "the destruction of thousands of small productive units," it has resulted in "the elimination of millions of jobs."

NAFTA not only decimated many Mexican small businesses, it also helped to destroy entire national industries. Before NAFTA, Mexico produced trains, tractors, and other industrial goods. They generally weren't exported, but that production made the economy more self-sufficient.

Many of these industries have wasted away. During the 2008 financial crisis, Mexico's economy shrank 6.6 percent — Latin America's steepest decline — because of its chronic dependence on the U.S. market.

Meanwhile, Mexican consumption of U.S. goods has skyrocketed, with Mexicans shopping in big box stores like Walmart and Costco. At these stores, even food items emblematic of Mexico like tortilla chips and salsa are brought in from the United States.

The result? Millions of small-scale producers, mom and pop shops, and other traditional Mexican employers were scrapped, and the national diet went downhill. The gusher of processed foods and beverages from the North has made Mexico the world's most obese nation, with diabetes its top cause of death.

Not everyone is a loser, of course. Mexico boasts the richest man in the world, Carlos Slim — who amassed his fortune from privatization schemes related to NAFTA. Mexico's economic elite, with its wealth securely deposited in banks in the United States and elsewhere, finds a lot to like in NAFTA.

But for the rest of the population, Mexico's experience with NAFTA shows why free trade and investment deals are bad not only for America's working families, but for working families all over the world.

That's why the wide-ranging Trans-Pacific Partnership President Barack Obama is now championing faces growing global resistance. After 20 years of NAFTA, the predictions we made that the agreement would cause massive social problems have proven true. It's become clear that these pacts can hurt people in every possible way.

Manuel Pérez-Rocha is an Institute for Policy Studies associate fellow. www.ips-dc.org


Help us bring you more news. Be a real reader: Support YubaNet

By submitting a comment you consent to our rules. You must use your real first and last name, not a nickname or alias. A comment here is just like a letter to the editor or a post on Facebook. Thank you.


Latest Headlines


Dave Johnson: Republicans Demand Flint-Like Solution To Puerto Rico Debt

Sam Pizzigati: The federal government can now spot a bug in space — so why can't they spot rich tax cheats here on the ground?

Robert Borosage: What Does Bernie Want?

Robert Reich: Why Trump Might Win

Chuck Collins: A Commencement Address for the Most Indebted Class Ever

Michael B. Keegan: A Coalition of the Unhinged

Bill Sher: Nothing Populist About Trump’s Campaign of Character Assassination

Cori Crider: CIA destruction of Senate torture report is stunning






NEWS . Fire News . Latest . Regional . California . USA . World . Op-Ed . Enviro . Sci/Tech . Life . Odd News . Cartoons
FEATURES . The Calendar .Weather . Sierra NightSky. Road Conditions
YubaNet.com . Advertising. About Us . Support YubaNet . Contact Us . Terms of Use . Privacy

YubaNet.com © 1999-2016
Nevada City, California (530) 478-9600